Most traders focus on developing strategies in order to make money. So do I, there is no other way around. However, your mindset is often “the missing link” in order to perform better. To get steady returns you have to focus on the mental part just as much as the trading numbers. For those not into trading this might sound a little weird. What does psychology have to do with hard and cold trading numbers? After trading for some years you’ll discover that trading is certainly not as easy as it seems, quite the opposite. If you can’t follow the rules of the strategy, you simply have no strategy.
My results from the end of 2011 until summer of 2012 were mediocre, to say the least. I did a in-depth analysis of my trading and concluded that my mindset was holding me back. My trading strategies weren’t that bad, I just needed to change my habits and my thinking. I have completely changed my working habits after this analysis: I spend less time doing actual trading and more time researching and doing other things not directly related to trading (like this blog for example). I’m forcing myself to don’t look at the P/L during the trading day and rather just focusing on my tasks. The result is that I make more money and I actually care a lot less about my P/L. I concentrate on executing my strategies. The P/L is just a byproduct of what I do. Actually, this blog helps me being focused and disciplined.
Now, underneath I’ll try to summarize my own findings after I revamped my trading style:
You should be relentless on developing skills in how to master yourself and the markets. Some traders love the action, others dream of easy money, but the really good traders think about how to develop strategies. The work should be a goal, money and action is just a byproduct. Trading is a performance field. Success is about talent, skills and work ethics. Not everyone can become a trader. Mark Minervi was interviewed in Jack Schwager’s Stock Market Wizards. Here is a quote from that interview (page 176):
“The fruits of your success will be in direct ratio to the honesty and sincerity of your own effort in keeping your own records, doing your own thinking, and reaching your own conclusions. In other words, take 100 percent responsibility for your results.”
This is the most important. You have to get an understanding on who you are and your personality traits. Are you introvert or extrovert? Are you disciplined? Are you able to work on your own? Are you confident by nature? What is your aim? Why do you trade? A lot of people “want to make a lot of money” and start trading. They want to stay at home and have no commuting. The dream of an easy life seems so appealing. Occasionally go to the cafe and trade from there. I guess this is the reason a lot of people want to trade. But if you don’t appreciate that trading is an intellectual endeavor you’ll most likely fail. If you concentrate on analysis and just executing your findings, you can once in a while realize your dreams and trade from cafes. But trading is solitary, it attracts people that are introverted. The ones with intuition backed up by gut feel can get some kind of a game going in a few months or a year or two but not for the long term, in my opinion. The ones that back up intuition with thinking take much longer to get a game plan and they can last longer. Extroverts with intuition backed up by thinking will take a long time to get going but once they master the game they have potentially have some something going. However, their biggest obstacle is implementing their plans, they have to master themselves and undergo personality change in order to get their trading implemented properly. But if they can change somewhat they can be really good traders.
If you decide to open a pizza shop, most likely you’ll set up some plans for how to proceed. Perhaps making budgets and even some marketing research to check the viability of the plan. Do you think a potential trader does all this? Probably not. But you need to have a business plan and develop some kind of methodology. This methodology has to be linked to your personality traits. It’s better to have a bad methodology than no methodology at all. This takes time, a lot of time. You first need an idea, some kind of hypotheses, and then you need to backtest this idea to check if it has any statistical edge. For some, that is the easy part. The tricky part is to execute is. It all looks so easy when you have the answer in front of you. Problem is, when trading you never know the future. All you know is the past. After a drawdown, you might lose faith in the system and stop trading, perhaps exactly at the wrong time. Therefore, you need to practice and stay focused on what you should do. Try to avoid thinking in terms of money. But by focusing on tasks, a lot of traders will be bored. They need action. They need to make a lot of money. They need it NOW. Extroverts are like this. Don’t fall prey to this. Concentrate on developing your skills and how to adapt to the markets and try to minimize your weaknesses. Be disciplined:
Discipline is for many a negative word. I quote from Wikipedia:
Self-discipline can be defined as the ability to motivate oneself in spite of a negative emotional state. Qualities associated with self-discipline include willpower, hard work, and persistence.
Self-discipline is the product of persisted willpower. Whereas willpower is the strength and ability to carryout a certain task, self-discipline is the ability to use it routinely and even automatically (as if through reflex). An analogy for the relationship between the two might be defined as follows: Where willpower is the muscle, self-discipline is the structured thought that controls that muscle.
Again, Mark Minervi gives a very good analogy:
“The first time I seriously watched a poker game in a casino I noticed that the average winning hand was over 50 USD, but that it only cost you 50 cents to see the first three cards. I couldn’t believe that for half a dollar I could get a pretty good idea of my chances of winning a hundred times that amount. If I folded fifty times and won only once, I would still win twice as much as I lost. Those seemed like terrific odds to me. That’s how I got started playing poker. My strategy was to only play super-high-probability hands. Schwager: Didn’t everyone just fold once you played a hand? No, and you know why? Because they were not disciplined, and they wanted to play. The key is to know when to do nothing. Most people, even if they have a winning strategy, will not follow it because they lack discipline.”
I guess willpower, hard work and persistence are not traits that many people have. No wonder this brings negative thoughts to many. However, trading is not a military boot camp, but be honest to yourself to check if you have any of these three traits. If not, trading can be quite hard. One other word that is not mentioned in the Wikipedia quote is rules. Yet another negative word! Is trading sadomasochism? Yes, it can be! As mentioned you need a methodology and that implies strict rules and systems. If you have found such a method, and that is no easy task either, the real tricky part is to execute the strategy. You need to apply it systematically. Hopefully you have some ideas about your personality traits so you’re able to deal with the strategy. Being disciplined can help you being confident:
Confident, but not overconfident
The key to trading success is emotional discipline. Making money has nothing to do with intelligence. To be a successful trader, you have to be able to admit mistakes. People who are very bright don’t make very many mistakes. Besides trading, there is probably no other profession where you have to admit when you’re wrong. In trading, you can’t hide your failures. – Victor Sperandeo
Trading is not different from any other demanding undertaking, it requires mastering the different stages of the learning curve and the quality of this learning process depends on how focused and disciplined the trader is in honoring his acquired skills. If you’re confident, it’s a lot easier to execute your methodology. To become confident you have to acquire the mentality mentioned above. If you master those, you have a lot better chance to be confident. However, there is thin line between confidence and overconfidence.
Breet Steenbarger has written an interesting book about trading psychology and also have a blog. According to him overconfidence is the worst trait a trader can have. Here is an excerpt from his blog:
Studies in behavioral finance find that about 3/4 of all traders rate their prowess as “above average”, despite the obvious reality that only half of us are better than the other half. This overconfidence, moreover, affects actual trading performance. Research by Terence Odean and colleagues finds that overconfidence affects frequency of trading, which in turn contributes to poor trading results. In one study of online traders, the group of traders favored high beta (volatile) small cap companies and tended to not diversify their portfolios. Their actual trading results slightly beat the small cap index, but after trading costs were factored in, they significantly underperformed the index. The most frequent traders were the ones who underperformed the index by the greatest margin…….One of my favorite studies of overconfidence came from the London Business School. Traders were shown price patterns and asked to figure out the market’s next direction and indicate their confidence in their prediction. The price patterns were generated entirely randomly. The traders with the highest confidence in their predictions traded the most frequently and incurred the greatest losses.
Steenbarger’s argument is a strong case for having a mechanical trading system. Certainly this applies for those who tend to be extroverts and/or impulsive.
Don’t be a hero. Don’t have an ego. Always question yourself and your ability. Don’t ever feel that you are very good. The second you do, you are dead… my guiding philosophy is playing great defense. If you make a good trade, don’t think it is because you have some uncanny foresight. Always maintain your sense of confidence, but keep it in check. – Paul Tudor Jones II
No ego and beliefs
They (traders) would rather lose money than admit they’re wrong… I became a winning trader when I was able to say, “To hell with my ego, making money is more important” – Marty Schwartz
Some people have a big ego. They need to be right. Some are besserwissers. These people can find it hard to trade completely mechanical. A mechanical system can have less than 50% win ratio and still make money. It feels pretty hard to have so many losers. Somehow they need to feed their ego. This trait is prevalent on online discussion forum. They brag about their prediction accuracy, how they have made 200% in 6 months and why others are wrong. Sure, there are successful discretionary traders, but probably a lot more successful mechanical traders. In trading you have to accept that losses are a part of doing business. In order to make money you have to admit losses. For some this is very hard. It leads to overtrading, getting stuck in losing trades and taking home small winners. But to succeed you have to divorce from your ego. Leave feelings aside.
Detachement to money
Money is just a way of keeping score. Try not to focus on money, it can be detrimental.Brett Steenbarger has done a lot of research on trading psychology. In 2004 he published a paper with Lo and Repin called Fear and Greed in Financial Markets: A Clinical Study of Day-Traders. They investigated several possible links between psychological factors and trading performance in a sample of 80 anonymous day-traders. Here is a highlight of their findings:
…..supporting the common wisdom that traders too emotionally affected by their daily profits-and-losses are, on average, less succesful……..This suggest that large “emotional swings” occurring within a 24-hour time scale hurt trading performance the most (page 19)…..our results show that extreme emotional responses are apparently counterproductive from the perspective of trading performance, and large changes in emotional state within short periods of time are among the most detrimental. (page 19)……For example, in a recent study by Fenton-O’Creevey et al. (2004) of 118 professional traders employed at investment banking institutions, they find that successful traders tend to be emotionally stable introverts who are open to new experiences (page 20)…..Ultimately, we hope to provide a scientic basis for the kind of recommendations for trading success made by Gilbert (2004) in his summary of Fenton-O’Creevey et al. (2004): Be an introvert. Keep your emotions stable. Stay open to new experiences. Oh, and try not to be misled by randomness, stop thinking you are in control of the
Fear of losing
For introverts the fear of losing can be an obstacle. Instead of focusing on what to do, you think about how much you can lose. You take profits quickly just to feel well. You might even end up increasing risk, even though you’re trying to minimize it. The biggest risk in trading is not getting the maximum profits from your methodology. The fear of losing will slow down your trading, especially after a string of losses. Every trader experience this feeling once in a while. If that happens it might be wise to take a break. If you can’t follow your methodology, you need a break. However, this simple advice is much easier to give than to take.
So to sum up trading is really simple, but still most of us make it really complicated (including myself): Here is my final words:
Trading is a probability game. Find a profitable methodology by testing and implement it. Diversify to several strategies (with lowest correlation possible). Try to make trading as easy and smooth as possible. Ignore money. Feel detachment to money. Focus on what you should do. Keep it simple!