Klinger Oscillator Strategy – What Is It And How Does It Perform? (Backtest)
Last Updated on May 3, 2023
Out of the hundreds or thousands of technical indicators and oscillators that exist, the Klinger oscillator indicator is not one that comes to mind first. However, because it is not well known doesn’t mean it doesn’t work or that we should dismiss it.
The Klinger Oscillator is a momentum indicator incorporating volume, price, and trend. We combined this with a signal line to generate buy and sell signals and spot divergence between the price action and the indicator.
In this article, we will analyze what the Klinger Oscillator is, how it works, and backtest it as a trading strategy.
Before you read the article, you might want to know that we have compiled a landing page of many different trading systems. We have hundreds of strategies with specific trading rules and backtests.
What is the Klinger Oscillator and how does it work?
The Klinger Oscillator is a technical indicator that measures the relationship between volume, price, and trend. It was developed by Stephen Klinger and published in Stock and Commodities Magazine in 1997. Thus, the strategy is relatively new.
The Klinger Oscillator can be fairly complex to calculate. Put simply, it is the difference between two exponential moving averages of volume force, typically the 34 VF EMA minus the 55 VF EMA. The volume force is an indicator that combines volume, price, and trend.
A 13-day exponential moving average of the Klinger indicator is used to trigger buy or sell signals. This technique is very similar to signals created with other indicators, such as the moving average convergence divergence (MACD).
Typically the Klinger Oscillator generates signals when it crosses under or over the signal line. Nevertheless, it can also be used to identify divergences when the indicator inputs are not confirming the direction of the price move. For example, a bullish signal can be generated when the indicator’s value rises while the asset’s price falls.
Kingler Oscillator example
In order to better understand how the Klinger Oscillator works, here is an example.
As you can see, in the beginning, the Klinger Oscillator is under the signal line. This means that we stay out of the market. However, when the Klinger Oscillator closes above the signal line, we buy the asset (green dot).
If the oscillator closes under the signal line, we sell (red dot). As with any indicator, it can generate false signals; however, being frequently wrong is part of successful trading (as long as the winners recoup the losers). The day after we sell it, we repurchase it (green dot) and hold it till the end.
In this timeframe (daily – 50 days), the Klinger Oscillator strategy returned -1.42% in SPY (the ETF that tracks S&P 500), while buy and hold returned 0.05%.
Klinger Oscillator trading rules
The trading rules are pretty simple:
- BUY SPY when the Klinger Oscillator is over the signal.
- SELL SPY when the Klinger Oscillator crosses under the signal.
Remember that the signal is the 13-day exponential moving average of the Klinger Oscillator.
Klinger Oscillator strategy backtest
We have backtested the strategy for S&P 500 (SPY) since 1993. The data is not adjusted for dividends and splits. Here is the equity curve:
The strategy metrics, performance, and statistics can be broken down into the following numbers:
- CAGR is 5.09% (buy and hold 7.46%)
- Time invested in the market is 48.38%
- Risk-adjusted return is 9.50%
- The average profit per trade is 1.00%
- The average holding time per trade is 11.5 days
- The win rate is 62.73%
- Maximum drawdown is -45.87% (-56.47%)
As you can see, the Klinger Oscillator performs reasonably well, but didn’t manage to beat buy and hold. Since 1993 it has taken 363 trades with an average profit of 1% per trade. However, compared to many other oscillating indicators, the drawdown is perhaps a tad higher and probably too high for most traders.
Klinger Oscillator conclusion
To sum up, the Klinger Oscillator is a useful technical indicator to incorporate into your trading. The win rate is high, and the average gain is good. Nevertheless, we think it would work best combined with another indicator rather than on its own.
We have written thousands of articles on this blog since we started in 2012. Many articles contain specific investment rules that can be backtested for profitability and performance metrics. The premium articles we charge a fee for: